Ep. 49 : Midnight Massacre - The Villisca Axe Murders

On June 9, 1912, a midnight massacre would change the town of Villisca, Iowa, forever, creating harsh divides between classes, races, families and churches. After attending Sunday service, the Moore family returned home with guests Ina and Lena Stillinger, where they shared a plate of milk and cookies before retiring for the evening. An unknown assailant waited in the wings and gruesomely butchered all six of the Moores and the two Stillinger children. The killer's identity remains a mystery, but he left behind tell-tale signs of someone who'd done this before, making the string of axe murders plaguing the Midwest one of America's first serial killings. We'll look at three possible suspects and analyze the implications their guilt had on Villisca. This is not a story with a happy ending, but we'll try to bring some levity with Halee's incredible Dead Velvet Cake. Happy Haunting!

The Victims

The Crime Scene

Villisca’s Suspects

Detective Wilkerson

Detective Wilkerson was dead set on pinning the crime on FF Jones. He claimed he had the evidence to prove it. He did not.

Reverend Kelly

Was it Henry Lee Moore?

Villisca Then & Now

Previous
Previous

Ep. 50 : The Legend of the Jersey Devil

Next
Next

Ep. 48 : The Mystery of Dyatlov Pass